Top 10


Top 10 for 2004

Rock

TheBigBlack

TheBigBlack's Rock Top 10

Rock came up better in the end than I had expected, and had a better showing than the previous couple of years. I actually had to cull a couple to get down to 10.

10

Contraband

Velvet Revolver
Contraband

Hard Rock | Album | 8 June 2004

 

As much as we all complained about this album, it put some MUSICIANS back on the radio, and that's worth a mention me thinks. Remove Weiland and pop someone like... say... Axl Rose on vocals, and the album would have been BRILLIANT.


09

A Crow Left Of The Murder...

Incubus
A Crow Left Of The Murder...

Alternative Rock | Album | 3 February 2004

 

Incubus has always made great and intelligent music for me, but was always a little too close to walking the radio song line. Now, with the album that finally leaves any chance of that behind (and the legions of radio rock fans that couldn't make this album out), I think this may be their best ever. All the clues left on 'Morningrise' to where a good Incubus album may be are realised here.


08

Bubblegum

Mark Lanegan Band
Bubblegum

Grunge Rock | Album | 10 August 2004

 

I have been a big fan of Mark Lanegan since the early 90s when he released his 'Whiskey For The Holy Ghost' acoustic album, then discovered the HUGE Screaming Trees back catalogue. Everything he has written since then has just gotten better and better. A brilliant blend of acoustic folk and rock.


07

Peace, Love, Death Metal

Eagles Of Death Metal
Peace, Love, Death Metal

Rock | Album | 23 March 2004

 

Josh Homme's band long before Kyuss or the QOTSA were even thought of finally got together and recorded their debut with him on drums (and leaving not long after...). This is a really groovy southern rock album, with an alternative feel. Unusual and unique. And has a stupid name.


06

The Dissociatives

The Dissociatives
The Dissociatives

Alternative Rock | Album | 5 April 2004

 

When I fluked upon this playing late one Saturday night on Rage, I got very excited! Could this be new Silverchair? But the style is wrong? NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! Then after a quick hunt on the net I was surprised to find Mr. Johns had teamed up with ol' buddy Paul Mac again. The 2000 E.P. 'I Can't Believe It's Not Rock!' left us all noting that it wasn't rock, and I expected more of the same. But this is Johns at his creative best. The album grew on me like an amoeba growing in a laboratory petri-dish, and I love it.


05

Sunrise Over Sea

John Butler Trio
Sunrise Over Sea

Alternative Rock | Album | 8 March 2004

 

The man is a master of the guitar and a genius song writer. Give him a jazz style percussive team to accompany his blues-riffed folk - and a masterpiece appears. The story goes that Sony America offered him a million bucks to publish the album in the U.S., but as they refused to press the cover on recycled paper, he signed with some small label for less than 100 grand... what a great hippy!


04

Seven Circles

The Tea Party
Seven Circles

Alternative Rock | Album | 17 August 2004

 

The Tea Party are one of the few bands that can be consistent and not go stale. This is a bit of a departure (with a more straight up rock feel and no eastern influences), but is still classic stuff.


03

Houses Of The Mole

Ministry
Houses Of The Mole

Metal (Industrial) | Album | 21 June 2004

 

Rock or Metal? I still class these guys as industrial alternative rock - but I'm very anal about such things. Just when you thought Jorg could never produce another thing of quality when loaded on so much blow and shoot, before your very ears comes what is possibly the best Ministry album ever! And every song starts with a W. Is that 'W' for 'Where's my veins?'


02

American Idiot

Green Day
American Idiot

Punk Rock | Album | 21 September 2004

 

Green Day can't do any wrong really. Billie Joe is the master of the 3 chord pop-punk style, and. and there is nothing else to say. So get stuffed.


01

With The Lights Out

Nirvana
With The Lights Out

Grunge Rock | Compilation Boxed Set | 23 November 2004

 

Wow! This is huge, with 3 CDs of nearly all unreleased (or rare) Nirvana, more Kurt Cobain demos than Courtney Love can claim ownership of, and a fitting end to the band that started the greatest revolution in rock since Hendrix pumped out Purple Haze at the Monterey Pop Festival in '67. Brilliant. JUST BRILLIANT.


TheBigBlack

TheBigBlack's Rock Honourable Mentions

NA

Pressure Chief

Cake
Pressure Chief

Alternative Rock | Album | 5 October 2004

 

Just because they are Cake. And they released an album. And it is funky.


NA

Still Hungry

Twisted Sister
Still Hungry

Hard Rock | Album | 19 October 2004

 

Re-recording their classic 1984 album 'Stay Hungry' with a 2004 production style, and opening the vaults to give us the left over tracks from the original sessions!


NA

Benaroya Hall, October 22nd 2003

Pearl Jam
Benaroya Hall, October 22nd 2003

Grunge Rock | Album | 27 July 2004

 

Giving us a live acoustic Pearl Jam set for charity. This has songs the band has never performed live before. Great stuff! Eddie - Will you marry me? Still 'no', huh? One day.


NA

Tonight Alright

Spiderbait
Tonight Alright

Alternative Rock | Album | 17 August 2004

 

With a pumping cover of 'Black Betty' (that topped the charts), and a follow-up single called 'Fucking Awesome' that radio couldn't play for obvious reasons, the 'bait is back! Perhaps they could show Powderfinger and Grinspoon how it is you play rock music, as they seem to have forgotten.


NA

Best Of Both Worlds (Oils On The Water)

Midnight Oil
Best Of Both Worlds (Oils On The Water)

Rock | Album + Video | 5 April 2004

 

The Oils finally releasing in conjunction with Triple J - The legendary 1985(?) Sydney Harbour / Goat Island concert on CD and DVD. Man - can Garrett dance or what? Yeah - he's dancing.


TheBigBlack

TheBigBlack's Rock Dishonourable Mentions

Less than the last couple of years, but enough to still have my rant.

NA

Mish Mash!

Regurgitator
Mish Mash!

Alternative Rock | Album | 15 November 2004

 

Thanks for entertaining us by thinking you could use a reality TV show to make a decent album, when it was obvious to all of us it was never gonna happen.


NA

How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb

U2
How To Dismantle An Atomic Bomb

Rock | Album | 19 November 2004

 

I smell something stale - Oh, it's seems it's time to throw the U2 away, as it's past it's use-by date. This is tired and boring. This is boring and tired. This is tired and dull. This is dull and boring. See how I wrote that over and over again, but changed it just a little - there you have the format used for this cattle dung.


NA

Stone Age Complication

Queens Of The Stone Age
Stone Age Complication

Alternative Rock | Compilation E.P. | 4 October 2004

 

Why when so much media hype and controversy is surrounding your band would you delay your new album and release a crappo E.P. of bad covers of bad songs? GIVE US THE DAMN ALBUM AND STOP WASTING OUR TIME AND MONEY.


NA

Collision Course

Jay-Z / Linkin Park
Collision Course

Alternative Rock | E.P. | 30 November 2004

 

OK - We had to suffer 'Reanimation' a couple of years back where rappers and DJs remixed the already agonisingly overplayed Linkin Park. Now we have to suffer another mini-album of the same tripe, only this time worse than the last? And the smart part is - of a 6 track album, they have capitalised with the single 'Numb' (again) by releasing it separately with 2 of the 6 songs on it also? And they say Lars loves the money.


NA

Braxton Hicks

Jebediah
Braxton Hicks

Alternative Rock | Album | 12 July 2004

 

With this radio friendly tripe, it's no wonder nobody bought your crappy album. Go back to Fremantle. You are a disgrace.


NA

eMOTIVe

A Perfect Circle
eMOTIVe

Alternative Rock | Album | 1 November 2004

 

When did 'A Perfect Circle' become 'A Ring Of Poo'? Let's get other's songs to save us time writing them, then make them really dull, so we sound moody and angsty - and we'll devote the whole thing to protest the war that ended 12 months ago... Maynard - Go back to Tool. We don't give 2 craps for your side project anymore.


mindkiller8

mk's Rock Top 10

Rock Top 10 will be appearing soon, but in the meantime these are some of the best (in no particular order.).

NA

Pressure Chief

Cake
Pressure Chief

Alternative Rock | Album | 5 October 2004

 


NA

Hangover Music Vol. VI

Black Label Society
Hangover Music Vol. VI

Heavy Metal | Album | 20 April 2004

 


NA

Peace, Love, Death Metal

Eagles Of Death Metal
Peace, Love, Death Metal

Rock | Album | 23 March 2004

 


NA

American Idiot

Green Day
American Idiot

Punk Rock | Album | 21 September 2004

 


NA

Thrills, Kills & Sunday Pills

Grinspoon
Thrills, Kills & Sunday Pills

Alternative Rock | Album | 20 September 2004

 


NA

Monolithic Baby!

Monster Magnet
Monolithic Baby!

Stoner Rock | Album | 25 May 2004

 


NA

Tonight Alright

Spiderbait
Tonight Alright

Alternative Rock | Album | 17 August 2004

 


Back To Top

Metal

TheBigBlack

TheBigBlack's Metal Top 10

This has got to be the biggest year in metal since the now legendary 1986 (Master Of Puppets / Reign In Blood / Peace Sells etc). This was hard work getting this list together. I have around 100 new metal releases for the year, and 90% were fantastic!

10

Epic

Borknagar
Epic

Black Metal (Progressive) | Album | 29 June 2004

 

This Norwegian Black Metal supa-group re-invent and refine their sound with each release. This album is possibly my favourite so far, with enough melody and aggression to really grab me.


09

Lemuria

Therion
Lemuria

Symphonic Metal | Album | 21 May 2004

 

This also includes the 'Sirius B' album - The 'issue 2 albums at one time' option has never really been pulled off by anyone but G'n'R in the past, but Therion have done a damn fine job of it here. A mixture of all of Therion's previous styles (operatic / power / death etc) beautifully wound into a 2 hour journey that is almost exhausting in intensity.


08

The Merciless

Aura Noir
The Merciless

Black Metal | Album | 1 October 2004

 

Brilliant old school black metal supa-group playing black metal how it should be - nasty, evil, fast, evil, angry, evil, underproduced, a bit more of some evil, and in white face makeup. Long live Satan apparently.


07

Fate Of Norns

Amon Amarth
Fate Of Norns

Death Metal (Melodic) | Album | 6 September 2004

 

I had never really noticed Amon Amarth before, but this album caught me by surprise. Pumping death metal in the style of Unleashed or Vader, with just enough originality to make it Top 10 worthy.


06

Nymphetamine

Cradle Of Filth
Nymphetamine

Black Metal | Album | 28 September 2004

 

I find that a lot of Cradle releases tend to blend into one long noise after a while due to Dani's vocals. For this reason they rarely make the 10. But this album is quite different - mellower (only in style - the lyrics still bite like rabid dogs), but still with a driving tempo, this is fantastic music for playing at parties... where murder is being plotted.


05

Vol. 3 (The Subliminal Verses)

Slipknot
Vol. 3 (The Subliminal Verses)

Nu Metal | Album | 25 May 2004

 

This is without a doubt, the best thing the 'knot have ever released, maggots. I'm sure there are adverts for this in magazines saying 'BUY THIS OR DIE!' - and if there isn't - there should be, damn it! They have mastered the melody, but amped up the volume - and with the masterful producer Rick Ruben twiddling their knobs (oh lordy!), how could it not be a classic?


04

Songs Of Darkness, Words Of Light

My Dying Bride
Songs Of Darkness, Words Of Light

Doom Metal | Album | 23 February 2004

 

MDB often make TheBigBlack Top 10, but this time they deserve it more than any other. By far the heaviest Bride album in years, with occasional death metal growls, once again this band have redefined what a gothic band should be in the new century.


03

The System Has Failed

Megadeth
The System Has Failed

Thrash Metal | Album | 14 September 2004

 

Mr. Mustaine has come through a treat for the 'deth's possible finale. With threads from previous albums, and shades of the entire back catalogue in the music, this is BRILLIANT. Go ahead - Kick The Chair.


02

Tempo Of The Damned

Exodus
Tempo Of The Damned

Thrash Metal | Album | 2 February 2004

 

Exodus are the biggest band never to be big in metal. They never recovered from losing Hammett to Metallica. They also never recovered from their debut album being released 18 months after it was recorded due to label issues. They also never recovered from losing a lead singer when about to record the next album. The list goes on - demos released as real albums by crappy record companies, lead singers dying, more lead singers leaving etc. Drugs. Alcohol. Yet still they manage to make one of the most inspired thrash albums in recent memory. And a special thanks goes out to Mr Hammett for allowing the band to finally record his Exodus era unreleased track 'Impaler'.


01

Chimera

Mayhem
Chimera

Black Metal | Album | 29 March 2004

 

Possibly the best (and apparently possibly the last) Mayhem album ever! Faster and angrier and eviler than ever imagined. Just when the black metal world had given up on Mayhem as being a dinosaur, they show Norway they still reign.


TheBigBlack

TheBigBlack's Metal Honourable Mentions

NA

The Greater Of Two Evils

Anthrax
The Greater Of Two Evils

Thrash Metal | Album | 23 November 2004

 

This would have made the 10, but for the fact that it is all re-recorded old songs from the Neil and Joey era, so it doesn't really qualify. Oh - and they are done better. Shut up mk - they are done BETTER!


NA

The Craving [2004 Remix & Remaster]

MD.45
The Craving [2004 Remix & Remaster]

Thrash Metal | Album | 24 July 2004

 

Thanks to Mr. Mustaine for re-releasing his '96 punk offering with his own vocals as it should have been in the first place.


NA

Scars Of The Crucifix

Deicide
Scars Of The Crucifix

Death Metal | Album | 23 February 2004

 

Once again Deicide have shown the world what death metal sounds like. The only reason this didn't make the 10 is that I am pretty certain it is the same album they have released since 1989 - they just call it a different name each time.


NA

New Found Power

Damageplan
New Found Power

Metal | Album | 10 February 2004

 

I didn't much care for the album - but it had Dime on it, so it deserves a mention. Enough said. R.I.P.


NA

Hangover Music Vol. VI

Black Label Society
Hangover Music Vol. VI

Heavy Metal | Album | 20 April 2004

 

A pretty good album, yes - but not quite 10 material - it does get a mention though, for Zakk's boldness to release an all-acoustic album. And because he includes the worst version of 'A Whiter Shade Of Pale' ever recorded on it, thinking its listenable.


NA

Probot

Probot
Probot

Metal | Album | 10 February 2004

 

Thanks to Dave Grohl, the world has an album that contains not only Lee Dorian and Cronos together, but Lemmy and the banshee King Diamond too! THIS IS JUST TOO MUCH! WHOO-HOO! I think the only thing that let me down a little on this is that under the great guitar riffs, Dave is still just a rock drummer really. Double kick Dave! Everyone's doing it buddy! DO IT!


NA

Salvation

Cult Of Luna
Salvation

Post-Metal | Album | 4 October 2004

 

Cult Of Luna amaze me, and not many bands do that anymore. This album is a brilliant collage of noise and distortion, which ebbs and flows like the ocean in a storm... crashing against the rocks of the shore.


NA

Archetype

Fear Factory
Archetype

Metal (Industrial) | Album | 19 April 2004

 

Fear Factory without Dino? Like toast without Vegemite they said - It can't be done - DAMMIT! IT SHOULDN'T BE DONE! But it has been, and it actually worked. Like taking the first bite from a slice of toast spread with Promite instead, this was still Vegemite, but with a slightly new (and very refreshing) flavour. And it was HEAVY!


NA

Live At Budokan

Dream Theater
Live At Budokan

Progressive Metal | Album | 4 October 2004

 

I am not a huge Dream Theater fan, and will never claim to be. Yeah - These boys can play like motherfuckers, but it is all a little to guitar wanky and mellow in places for the wall of noise these damned ears deserve. So why is this here? I can't say - but I can say I gave all 3 CDs a hell of a listen, and this is magnificent from start to finish.


TheBigBlack

TheBigBlack's Metal Dishonourable Mentions

NA

So Far, So Good... So What? [2004 Remix & Remaster]

Megadeth
So Far, So Good... So What? [2004 Remix & Remaster]

Thrash Metal | Album | 24 July 2004

 

Dishonourable Mention for being remixed by General Mustaine to now have the TRUMPETS in the scorching opener 'Into The Lungs Of Hell' EVEN LOUDER. What was he thinking? What was he THINKING? In 1988 when he put them there the first time WHAT WAS HE THINKING?


mindkiller8

mk's Metal Top 10

OK - Having more than 3 months to listen to a myriad of goodies from 2004, here's a list with a little more effort. Bring on 2005!!!!! Yeah I know it's almost July!!

10

Circle Of Snakes

Danzig
Circle Of Snakes

Metal | Album | 31 August 2004

 

Some crunchy mid tempo guitars and I'm anyone's!! Yep I know this guy has done some great things in metal and I've ignored them all (including his Misfits work), but this release is impressive... Simple, but impressive.


09

Tempo Of The Damned

Exodus
Tempo Of The Damned

Thrash Metal | Album | 2 February 2004

 

OK - Another surprise. Scar Spangled Banner is brilliant. Souza's vox are infectious. Actually if you see what else has made my Top 10 this is a small trend at the moment (see Aura Noir and Cadaver vocals). This is just great old fashioned speed man!!!


08

Chimera

Mayhem
Chimera

Black Metal | Album | 29 March 2004

 

Each song has a great riff in it that keeps you listening for it to come around again. That's why it scraped in ahead of the others.


07

Necrosis

Cadaver
Necrosis

Death Metal | Album | 24 April 2004

 

Almost the spitting image of Aura Noir's latest. Grumpy vocals and straight up speed. Brilliant!!!


06

The Merciless

Aura Noir
The Merciless

Black Metal | Album | 1 October 2004

 

Nothing ground breaking here in terms of sound. Again just some really catchy tunes.


05

Buried In Oblivion

Into Eternity
Buried In Oblivion

Death Metal | Album | 10 February 2004

 

The surprise for me. This is just completely against all I stand for (in a wanky clean cut guitars sense at least) but something made me stand up and take notice - glimpses of grumpy guitars in between the clean and the vox change is different - I don't think I could stand a whole album of just one type. Impressive.


04

Ampeauty

Pungent Stench
Ampeauty

Death Metal | Album | 13 September 2004

 

Have loved these no thrills metallers for years. Glad to see they are back to their putrid, horrid, smelling best. And what a great theme for an album!


03

Salvation

Cult Of Luna
Salvation

Post-Metal | Album | 4 October 2004

 

A new sound that has grown on me. This and ISIS were great releases this year. Definitely need to be in the mood for it, but the intricacies with the occasional growling vocals blending in is a catchy mix.


02

The System Has Failed

Megadeth
The System Has Failed

Thrash Metal | Album | 14 September 2004

 

Yes, it does grow on you. I think this record has got me over 'Bring back the 'Rust' days' phobia. Sure I've listened to and admired all releases since that epic - but it's always been a 'take-it-or-leave-it' relationship. This has me interested in revisiting those albums again. Keep the Megadeth juggernaut running Droogie Dave - just one more time at least. AND YOU'D BETTER COME TO ADELAIDE!!!!


01

Vol. 3 (The Subliminal Verses)

Slipknot
Vol. 3 (The Subliminal Verses)

Nu Metal | Album | 25 May 2004

 

Wow - what a record!!! It's got it all. Some killer riffs, angry vox, and well timed ballads (which I normally wouldn't condone). I actually didn't like this the first time I listened. I was wrong.


mindkiller8

mk's Metal Honourable Mentions

In such a tough year a lot of good music misses out (in no particular order):

NA

Demigod

Behemoth
Demigod

Death Metal (Blackened) | Album | 25 October 2004

 

Hey - Some don't mind if you pour a bucket load of spit over your mic, but this ruins it for me.


NA

The Wretched Spawn

Cannibal Corpse
The Wretched Spawn

Death Metal | Album | 24 February 2004

 

The perennials in filth and off-putting song titles. They keep spewing out the same old stuff. Good for a listen, but a bit boring now.


NA

Nymphetamine

Cradle Of Filth
Nymphetamine

Black Metal | Album | 28 September 2004

 

Got a little boring in the end. I think this is the year of short albums for me.


NA

The Negation

Decapitated
The Negation

Death Metal (Technical) | Album | 9 March 2004

 

Some great short catchy songs in this lot. I just like the other shorter catchier songs better.


NA

Scars Of The Crucifix

Deicide
Scars Of The Crucifix

Death Metal | Album | 23 February 2004

 

Hey - this is good. Maybe I should have put it in my Top 10. Could it be the last one under the Deicide name???


NA

Isa

Enslaved
Isa

Black Metal (Progressive) | Album | 1 November 2004

 

See Deicide. Maybe we could stretch this to a Top 15 Zan???


NA

Archetype

Fear Factory
Archetype

Metal (Industrial) | Album | 19 April 2004

 

Sad as it is to say - one of my fave bands has rolled out something very similar to previous releases but just doesn't grab me. There are some good songs in there - Cyberwaste (a great tribute to Dino), but I was maybe looking for something a little different without Dino there and given the success (or slight lack of) of recent efforts.


NA

Panopticon

Isis
Panopticon

Metal | Album | 19 August 2004

 

Very similar to Cult Of Luna's release. I liked that one a little better as a complete album.


NA

Morke Gravers Kammer

Khold
Morke Gravers Kammer

Black Metal | Album | 2004

 

Unlike most listed here I have never heard of these guys. Have a great sound. Mixing the theatrical (sort of - I did shudder when I wrote that) with a progressive sound is cool with me.


NA

Houses Of The Mole

Ministry
Houses Of The Mole

Metal (Industrial) | Album | 21 June 2004

 

Love these guys and like this album, but I'm sick of the political stance in music - thank you Mr. Marley. Get back to singing about Jesus and those damn hot rods!!! Far more sensible topics.


NA

Inferno

Motorhead
Inferno

Hard Rock | Album | 22 June 2004

 

Let's put the record straight - never been much of a fan of the music, but am a fan of the man.


NA

New Found Power

Damageplan
New Found Power

Metal | Album | 10 February 2004

 

The last we will hear of Dimebag. \m/


Back To Top

Last Data Update: